Dadabhoy, Ambereen. "Early modern Orientalism." Throughlines. www.throughlines.org/suite-content/early-modern-orientalism. [Date accessed].

Early modern Orientalism

Deconstructing enduring fictions about Islam and Muslims

Download the transcript
Ambereen Dadabhoy
Harvey Mudd College

This course, created by Ambereen Dadabhoy, couples Edward Said's theorization of Orientalism with early modern period texts. Students will examine traces of Orientalist ideas and stereotypes, and how they are being used to create a particular European orientation toward Islam and Muslims across time.  

The course starts in the late medieval period, reading several texts by European and English writers across different genres. These readings demonstrate how early modern European cultures were already global in their engagement with peoples across a variety of different belief systems and geographies. Examining these exposures combats the false notion of a totally insular England and Europe, one that had no knowledge of or experience with people from different cultures, religions, or races.  

By the end of the semester, students will see how ideas about Islam and Muslims have a long history in the West and that this history has many enduring fictions. This is especially important in our current moment, with a Western-backed Israeli genocide in Palestine. Understanding the longue durée of Orientalism, and how tropes about Islam and Muslims change and shift according to the contingencies of power, exposes Europe's very long interest in and engagement with Islamicate cultures and its peoples.  

Readings

  • Edward Said, Orientalism, Introduction, Chapter 1 
  • Adam J. Silverstein, A Short Introduction to Islamic History
  • Anon, The King of Tars
  • Chaucer, "The Man of Law's Tale" - The Canterbury Tales
  • Anon, The Song of Roland
  • Christopher Marlowe, Tamburlaine
  • William Shakespeare, Othello
  • Philip Massinger, The Renegado
  • Richard Knolles, General History of the Turkes (selections) 
  • Nicolas de Nicolay, The Navigations, Peregrinations and Voyages Made into Turkie (selections) 
  • George Sandys, Relation of a Journey (selections) 
  • Paul Rycaut, The Present State of the Ottoman Empire (selections) 

Preview image: Places of Mind: A Life of Edward Said (Farrar, Straus, and Giroux).

Download this syllabus

Further learning

Activity

Tracing tropes

Ambereen Dadabhoy’s semester-long sequence of assignments aims to support students in their own knowledge production through the interpretations of primary texts.

Ambereen Dadabhoy
Video

Islam and the West

Guiding students through early modern texts, Ambereen Dadabhoy reveals the entangled relationship between Christian Europe and Muslim culture.

Ambereen Dadabhoy

Recommended

RaceB4Race Highlight

Muslims and racial profiling in early modern England

Hassana Moosa here draws upon the critical tools of premodern critical race studies and Shakespeare studies to investigate genealogies of early modern race-making as they pertain to Muslims.

Hassana Moosa
RaceB4Race Highlight

Defining race, periodizing race

In her 2019 RaceB4Race talk at the Folger Shakespeare Library, Geraldine Heng argues for thinking about race in transhistorical terms.

Geraldine Heng
Reading list

Indigenous Shakespeares

Selected readings to contextualize Shakespeare and indigeneity in your classroom.

Madeline Sayet